theMGZS.co.uk  :: MG ZS forum

theMGZS.co.uk :: MG ZS forum (https://www.themgzs.co.uk/vb/index.php)
-   General Discussion (https://www.themgzs.co.uk/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   Non starter (https://www.themgzs.co.uk/vb/showthread.php?t=23608)

welshone 06-12-12 08:35 PM

Non starter
 
Tried to start the car this morning and it wouldn't. All dash lights came on and all other lights worked but no engine.

Got home from work and tried again and it fired first time.

It was very cold this morning it was reading -5 in Mrs Welshones 307.

So my question is what could freeze to stop the car from starting?????

petet16 06-12-12 08:50 PM

Did it turn over, or did you get the solenoid clicking.

welshone 06-12-12 09:17 PM

got nothing just the lights on the dash. Did hear the fuel pump prime.

Dave 06-12-12 10:46 PM

Check the small spade connector on the starter motor, probably a bad contact.

Cheers
Dave

Dan1971 07-12-12 06:19 AM

Mine too yesterday .... Went to take it out just to give it a run. Haven't driven it for a couple of weeks and when I have done, it's just been for a couple of miles. This was after some snow and a couple of very cold nights ...

Click click click ..... Starter or battery ? Read up on it a bit yesterday and I'm hoping that the battery is flat and the clicking is the starter trying, but the battery doesn't have the power to turn the crank .... or so it said .... I have noticed that it was a little slower turning over the last few times ....

stamford 07-12-12 06:56 AM

Most likely the starter solenoid spade connection, if the battery was dying then it wouldn't have started later in the day.

Dan, it could well be the battery for you as this cold weather will show up batteries that are on their last legs. Give it an overnight charge so it is full, then see how this fares over the coming weeks, if it drops again then it'll need changing.

carmadbaker 07-12-12 07:11 AM

I would go with Mick and say battery failing. They really dont deal with the cold that well!

ZS 07-12-12 07:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stamford (Post 285970)
...see how this fares over the coming weeks, if it drops again then it'll need changing.

Next week will be the tester! Apparently we on the south coast are looking at a cold snap of temperatures around -15 Degrees Centigrade next week! I'd hate to see how cold the people up north are going to get...

Dan1971 07-12-12 07:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stamford (Post 285970)
Most likely the starter solenoid spade connection, if the battery was dying then it wouldn't have started later in the day.

Give it an overnight charge so it is full, then see how this fares over the coming weeks, if it drops again then it'll need changing.

Ta ... Ain't got a charger and they are £25 in Halfords. Just had a butchers on the bay of E and a new battery with 4 yr guarantee - plenty for me ;) - is only £45. I can see where this is going already .... Jump start this morning when it stops raining to see if it's the battery, then an order later if it is. Cheers ..... And sorry for the hijack .....

Nobrainer 07-12-12 08:28 AM

I'll preempt the which battery questions www.themgzs.co.uk/vb/showthread.php?t=23020&highlight=battery

Dan1971 07-12-12 08:41 AM

Cheers - was going for this one - free next day delivery. Not a fancy name, but power is power isn't it ?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/2511887973...84.m1423.l2649

Nobrainer 07-12-12 09:26 AM

Personally I'd take the bosch. At least you can take it back without a problem should you need to. Free next day delivery too.

Dan1971 07-12-12 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nobrainer (Post 285995)
... Free next day delivery too.

Seriously ... ? Fair enough. Where do I get that discount code ?

welshone 22-12-12 10:35 AM

OK back to this one. It's a complete none starter now. I've cleaned the connections as advised, I've fully charged the battery and still nothing and i've tried jump leads and still no joy.

All the electrics seem to work but when tried to start there is just nothing from the engine. Any more help would be very much appreciated before I go spending money I haven't really got on items such as the starter motor or ignition barrel.

I must add there where no fault codes found on a scan.

peterzs 22-12-12 10:47 AM

Reader on it to see if any faults logged up???

Crank/cam sensor??

Plenty of fuel??

Earth to the slam panel and to the gearbox OK??

Is the engine spinning over, or wont it even do that?? If it does spin is it quick or slow??

talkingcars 22-12-12 10:48 AM

Sounds very much like the starter to me. Mine was working fine and then suddenly nothing, when you turned the key the headlights didn't dim as they should when the starter draws current. RAC came out and push started the car to get me home, next morning it struggled but did fire up so I took the car to the garage, they replaced the starter and it's been fine ever since.

I did notice it was turning better with the new starter.

Try the headlight test on your's to see if it's the starter and jump leads direct to the starter should turn it if the ignition is at fault.

welshone 22-12-12 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by peterzs (Post 288489)
Reader on it to see if any faults logged up??? No faults

Crank/cam sensor??
scan should have picked this up??

Plenty of fuel??
More then enough

Earth to the slam panel and to the gearbox OK??
Check and cleaned

Is the engine spinning over, or wont it even do that?? If it does spin is it quick or slow??
Doing nothing at all.


.

welshone 22-12-12 10:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by talkingcars (Post 288491)
Sounds very much like the starter to me. Mine was working fine and then suddenly nothing, when you turned the key the headlights didn't dim as they should when the starter draws current. RAC came out and push started the car to get me home, next morning it struggled but did fire up so I took the car to the garage, they replaced the starter and it's been fine ever since.

I did notice it was turning better with the new starter.

Try the headlight test on your's to see if it's the starter and jump leads direct to the starter should turn it if the ignition is at fault.

Yep did the headlight test and no dimness to them.

So hopefully sounds like the starter then :)

talkingcars 22-12-12 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by welshone (Post 288498)
Yep did the headlight test and no dimness to them.

So hopefully sounds like the starter then :)

Whip it out and see if it spins with jump leads on the terminals.

I know a man who works in the parts business, he may be able to get one at a good price.

peterzs 22-12-12 10:57 AM

Sounds like the starter motor.

Might be worth getting it off and testing it.

Someone on here posted up new ones that looked a good price.

petet16 22-12-12 11:02 AM

This one
http://www.themgzs.co.uk/vb/showthread.php?t=23757

welshone 22-12-12 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by peterzs (Post 288500)
Sounds like the starter motor.

Might be worth getting it off and testing it.

Someone on here posted up new ones that looked a good price.

Quote:

Originally Posted by talkingcars (Post 288499)
Whip it out and see if it spins with jump leads on the terminals.

I know a man who works in the parts business, he may be able to get one at a good price.

Thanks guys, it's a bit wet out there at the mount but when it gets a little less wet i'll give it a bash. luckily i've got the Mrs Welshone's car spare to use for the next two weeks for work so no major rush at the moment But sooner the better as for the past few days i've been driving around in a pug 307 and a vauxhall agila (or ugila as i like to call it lol) and it's getting a bit depressing lol

welshone 22-12-12 11:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by petet16 (Post 288503)

Thanks for the link :)

welshone 29-12-12 09:08 AM

Ok back to this lovely problem :/


Just took off the starter and jump leaded it to my battery and to all worked as it should. Motor worked and it popped out like it should.

Put it back on and still no start :(.

I'm going to put a starter button in now at the ignition barrel see if i have a dodgy ignition barrel.

Anymore suggestions of what to check would be great :)

Dan1971 29-12-12 09:27 AM

Is it turning but not catching, or doing nothing at all ?

welshone 29-12-12 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan1971 (Post 289472)
Is it turning but not catching, or doing nothing at all ?

Doing nothing :(

petet16 29-12-12 09:44 AM

Have you tried using a spare jump lead to earth the engine to the body ?

welshone 29-12-12 09:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by petet16 (Post 289477)
Have you tried using a spare jump lead to earth the engine to the body ?

I'll give that a go now :)

Update::

Just tried and still no joy :(

Dan1971 29-12-12 10:04 AM

Clueless mate .... sorry.

Have you had the AA or similar out ?

petet16 29-12-12 10:13 AM

Another possibility is the starter relay in the engine bay fuse box.

Dan1971 29-12-12 10:31 AM

Haynes manual says -
  • battery terminal connections loose or corroded
  • battery discharged or faulty
  • broken loose or disconnected wiring in the starting circuit
  • defective starter solenoid or switch
  • defective starter motor
  • starter pinion or flywheel ring gear teeth loose or broken
  • engine earth strap broken or disconnected

welshone 29-12-12 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by petet16 (Post 289483)
Another possibility is the starter relay in the engine bay fuse box.

Checked them, all ok

welshone 29-12-12 01:01 PM

[*]battery terminal connections loose or corroded

Cleaned and reconnected
[*]battery discharged or faulty

Tried jumping it from another car with no luck.
[*]broken loose or disconnected wiring in the starting circuit

This is my thought but where I have no idea :(
[*]defective starter solenoid or switch

Works when connected direct to battery
[*]defective starter motor

Works when connected direct to battery
[*]starter pinion or flywheel ring gear teeth loose or broken

Could be but how do I check?
[*]engine earth strap broken or disconnected

Checked and cleaned and used jump lead as suggested.


Now it's raining again and back to the drawing board me thinks lol

petet16 29-12-12 01:53 PM

I think the solenoid on the starter motor may be goosed.

welshone 30-12-12 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by petet16 (Post 289533)
I think the solenoid on the starter motor may be goosed.

Solenoid works straight from battery.

welshone 30-12-12 03:14 PM

Still no joy with this. Anymore ideas ???

peterzs 30-12-12 03:16 PM

You put a new battery in the key fob. (bit of grasping at straws).

welshone 30-12-12 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by peterzs (Post 289741)
You put a new battery in the key fob. (bit of grasping at straws).

Tried my both fobs both unlock and lock car but nothing at position 3 on ignition

peterzs 30-12-12 03:22 PM

For a couple of quid, I'd try a new battery!!

petet16 30-12-12 03:22 PM

As everything else seems to have been exhausted, the ignition switch would be another possibility.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ? 2010 theMGZS.co.uk