Saloon vs hatch

[Jay-ZS+]

Originally Posted by WalkerDnB

that a photo shop or has it been done?

Definitely been done, car used to be mine

[WalkerDnB]

looks very smart that

[red robbo]

Saloon for me.

[talkingcars]

Originally Posted by redzed

............wsr told me this because it is less like the honda hatch and therefore a saloon is more mg/rover.............

Amen

[Quadcam24]

Originally Posted by petet16

You have your opinion and I have mine, they differ.

difference is my opinion is based on personal experience over some years, doing countless track days with many different zs....unless you have done the same you cannot compare, you cant push the cars to their true limits on roads and you cant drive flat out in your car with your mates in their cars on the roads either, You also have to have the same tyres, same mods etc, ive done all this testing and the hatch is very marginally quicker around a lap.

[MG 53 ZED]

Has to be the saloon for me, nowt wrong with the hatch there are some nice examples out there, i just prefer the look of the saloon.

[Jay-ZS+]

Originally Posted by Quadcam24

difference is my opinion is based on personal experience over some years, doing countless track days with many different zs....unless you have done the same you cannot compare, you cant push the cars to their true limits on roads and you cant drive flat out in your car with your mates in their cars on the roads either, You also have to have the same tyres, same mods etc, ive done all this testing and the hatch is very marginally quicker around a lap.

As you say 'the hatch is very marginally quicker around a lap' and 'you cant push the cars to their true limits on roads', where most use their cars, then the handling of the two could be said to be equal as your not driving to their limits anyway. So it comes back to looks, and the hatch still looks as if its missing a bit off the end!

[zsserbia]

I wonder what Bernie and Leepu would say

[Jay-ZS+]

Originally Posted by zsserbia

I wonder what Bernie and Leepu would say

Those two crack me up! Nutters both of them!!

[grimmy]

Saloon ftw.